November 19, 2012

Will Ethics and Education Ever Matter?


As a lifelong Tar Heel fan, the recent academic issues that have embroiled the athletic department have hurt my heart. I think it was just my naiveté that hoped that Carolina was above the fray. Now it’s hard to watch the sports and not just be cynical.
College sports, so closely tied to American higher education, are under threat. Pushed on all sides for quick success, Coaches, Administrators, Athletic Directors, and University Presidents have adopted a win-at-any price mentality. Graduation rates are abysmal, admission standards are ignored, and teams pay enormous sums for the opportunity to destroy hapless foes. (See the SEC football schedule this past weekend) Thinking they can just turn a blind eye to what they most assuredly know is the common practice.
Money flows freely between TV networks and university bank accounts, even as the quality of the education steadily decays. Rather than an expectation of honor, discipline, and teamwork, young men are constantly bombarded by the supposed importance of their personal self-worth. A select few teams like my UNC Tar Heels have perfected the fraud, sacrificing their academic missions, and student-athletes, in the name of relevance and revenue. These schools are lauded for their on-field excellence, even as they create horrifying monuments of shame off the playing fields and courts. This travesty of a system continues to gorge itself, with calls for change dismissed as hopeless idealism.
This wake-up call has me firmly believing that you can count on every institution to have this problem. Aside from Notre Dame, Stanford, Vanderbilt and Northwestern, the other 296 NCAA schools are falling woefully below standard. Don’t tell me how your school does this or that, with a deeper look you too will be like me and soon be smacked into reality.
And to the Universities that continue this fraud, you should be asked to reach out to the countless decades of athletes who perpetuate our society with very little employable skills and pay for them a REAL education and guarantee their degree.
Some would say that schools like the above 4 could not compete in the present climate.  I’m proud that Notre Dame is competing in football and also is #1 in graduation rates.
I want a university that I can sit in my chair and be proud of on the field, in the classroom, and contributing to society. I need to believe once again that ethics and education matter.